MarginMints — Know what you keep

MarginMints Guides · Last reviewed November 8, 2026

Where to Sell Handmade Items

Where to sell handmade items depends on two things: how much traffic you can bring yourself, and what share of each sale you are willing to pay for traffic you did not bring. If you need buyers to find you, start on Etsy — it is where handmade buyers already search. If you already have an audience of your own, your own Shopify store keeps the most of every sale. Amazon Handmade buys you Amazon's traffic at the highest fee in this guide, eBay works best for one-off and vintage-adjacent pieces, and Facebook Marketplace is free only when the buyer collects in person.

This guide compares the five main options on the same $30 handmade item — same price, no shipping charged, no sales tax — so the fee math is directly comparable. Every rate below is the platform's published US rate, checked in November 2026 against the platform's own fee pages. If you charge for shipping, remember that Etsy, Amazon Handmade and eBay all charge their percentage fees on the shipping you charge too, so the numbers below are a floor, not a ceiling.

Where to sell handmade items: the $30 test

One item, $30, no shipping charged, no sales tax. "You keep" is the price minus platform fees only — your material cost, packaging and the label still come out of it.

PlatformFees on a $30 saleYou keepPlatform's take
Etsy$0.20 listing + 6.5% transaction + 3% + $0.25 processing$26.7011.0%
Amazon Handmade15% referral fee$25.5015.0%
eBay13.6% final value fee + $0.40 per-order fee$25.5214.9%
Facebook Marketplace (shipped)10% of the transaction$27.0010.0%
Facebook Marketplace (local pickup)$0$30.000%
Shopify Basic (own store)2.9% + $0.30 card processing (+ $39/mo plan)$28.83*3.9%*

* Shopify's $28.83 is before the $39 monthly plan cost — the plan is a fixed cost, so the per-order figure only wins once you sell enough volume. See the Shopify section below for the break-even.

Fee data last reviewed: November 8, 2026. Rates are the platforms' published US rates. Etsy, Amazon and eBay all revise fees during the year, so confirm your exact rate on the platform's own fee page before you price a product — a one-point change is $0.30 on every $30 sale.

Etsy — the default for handmade

Etsy is still the first place handmade buyers look, and that is its whole advantage: you list, and people who are already shopping for handmade goods find you. The cost is a stack of three fees on every sale. On a $30 item with no shipping charged, the listing fee is $0.20, the transaction fee is 6.5% of the price ($1.95), and US payment processing is 3% + $0.25 ($1.15). Total fees $3.30, and you keep $26.70 before your own costs.

Two things catch new sellers out. First, the transaction fee also applies to the shipping you charge, and the processing fee applies to the whole amount the buyer pays including tax — so a $30 item with $6 shipping costs more in fees than the $3.30 above. Second, Offsite Ads: if a sale comes through an ad Etsy placed for you, Etsy adds 15% (12% once your shop passes $10,000 in trailing-12-month sales), capped at $100 per order. Under $10,000 you can opt out; over it, participation is mandatory. On a $30 Offsite Ads sale the extra fee is $4.50, which turns the $26.70 keep into $22.20. Price with that in mind, and read the full schedule in Etsy's Fees & Payments Policy.

Etsy suits makers who want discovery without building an audience first — jewellery, candles, crochet, prints, personalised gifts. It suits you less once your own following does the selling, because then you are paying for traffic you brought yourself. Run your exact numbers in the Etsy fee calculator.

Amazon Handmade — the biggest audience, the biggest cut

Amazon Handmade is a maker-only storefront inside Amazon: buyers trust it because every seller passes an artisan application, and you get access to Amazon's traffic. The fee is simple — a flat 15% referral fee on the total sale price including any shipping you charge, or $0.30, whichever is greater. On a $30 item that is $4.50, and you keep $25.50. There is no listing fee, and the referral fee already covers payment processing, so there is no separate processing charge.

The monthly fee needs a careful read. Handmade requires a Professional selling plan, which normally costs $39.99 a month — but Amazon waives the ongoing monthly fee for approved Handmade sellers after a one-time, first-month payment, a saving of $480 a year. So your fixed cost is effectively one month of $39.99, not $39.99 every month. Fulfilment is extra either way: FBA fees or your own shipping sit on top of the 15%. See the official Amazon Handmade programme page for the current terms and the application.

Handmade suits makers whose products fit Amazon's categories (home, jewellery, art, baby, pet supplies and more) and who want scale without building a brand audience. It suits you less if your margin is thin — 15% is the steepest cut in this guide — or if your work does not fit the handmade categories Amazon allows.

eBay — best for one-offs and vintage-adjacent pieces

eBay is not a handmade-first marketplace, but it is where buyers go for one-of-a-kind, vintage-adjacent and collectible pieces, and handmade items that fit that frame sell well there. The fee is a 13.6% final value fee on the total amount of the sale — item price plus shipping charged plus sales tax — in most categories, plus a per-order fee. On a $30 item with no shipping charged and no tax, the final value fee is $4.08 and the per-order fee is $0.40, because the per-order fee is $0.30 on orders of $10 or less and $0.40 on orders over $10. Total fees $4.48, and you keep $25.52.

Listings are cheap: the first 250 listings each month are free, then $0.35 per listing. There is no monthly plan unless you choose a Store subscription, which lowers the final value fee to 12.7% on a Basic Store. The catch is the fee base — because the percentage applies to shipping and tax as well as the item price, a $30 item with $8 shipping is charged on $38, not $30. Check the category table before you list, because a handful of categories (books and media at 15.3%, guitars at 6.7%) use different rates. eBay's own selling-fees page carries the current table; our eBay fees guide walks through it with worked examples.

Facebook Marketplace — free locally, 10% shipped

Facebook Marketplace is the cheapest option in this guide and the most limited. A local pickup sale paid in person carries no Meta selling fee at all: sell a $30 handmade piece to a local buyer and you keep the full $30.00. Shipped orders are a different story — orders paid through Marketplace checkout cost 10% of the whole transaction (item price plus shipping plus applicable tax), with a $0.80 minimum. On a $30 shipped item with no shipping charged, that is $3.00, and you keep $27.00.

Two limits matter. First, checkout with shipping is US-only, and buyers expect Marketplace prices to be low — it is a bargain-hunting audience, not a handmade-browsing one, so premium pricing is a harder sell here than on Etsy. Second, you get almost no seller tools: no shopfront, no branding, no reviews system that carries over. It is excellent for bulky pieces (furniture, large planters, wreaths) where local buyers collect and shipping would eat the margin anyway, and for clearing one-off pieces fast. Run the shipped maths in the Facebook Marketplace fee calculator.

Shopify — your own store, your own traffic

A Shopify store is not a marketplace: nobody browses it by accident. What you buy for $39 a month on the Basic plan (monthly billing; $29 a month billed yearly) is a storefront you own, with the lowest per-order cost in this guide. Online card payments through Shopify Payments cost 2.9% + $0.30 per order, so a $30 sale costs $1.17 in processing and you keep $28.83 before the plan cost. There is no platform percentage on top — but if you use a third-party payment provider instead of Shopify Payments, Shopify adds a 2% transaction fee on Basic.

The break-even against Etsy is simple. Etsy costs $3.30 per $30 order; Shopify costs $1.17, a saving of $2.13 per order. The plan costs $39 a month, so $39 ÷ $2.13 = 18.3 — at 19 orders a month, the $40.47 you save beats the $39 plan, and every order after that is cheaper than Etsy. Below 19 orders a month, Etsy is cheaper overall. The honest catch is traffic: Shopify gives you no buyers, so the maths only works if you already have an audience — from Etsy, social media, craft fairs or email — to send to the store. Model your own volume in the Shopify profit calculator.

Craft fairs and local markets — briefly

In-person markets take no percentage of your sales. You pay a booth fee, which varies widely by event and city, and keep everything you sell minus your costs. They are the best place to test a new product (you watch people pick it up, ask questions and walk away), to build a local following, and to sell bulky or fragile pieces that are expensive to ship. Their weakness is the same as their strength: one event reaches only the people in the room, and a slow day still costs you the booth fee. Treat fairs as a marketing channel that pays for itself, not as your only sales channel.

How to choose

Just starting out, no audience yet: Etsy. It is the only option here where buyers arrive on their own. Already selling 20+ orders a month: add your own Shopify store and move your repeat buyers there — the fee saving pays for the plan. Want maximum reach and can absorb 15%: Amazon Handmade, if your products fit its categories and you pass the application. One-off, vintage-style or collectible pieces: eBay. Bulky pieces or local buyers: Facebook Marketplace local pickup, where the fee is zero. Most working makers end up on two channels: one marketplace for discovery, and their own store for the customers they keep. Compare all five side by side in the 7-marketplace fee comparison.

One last note: Temu is not a handmade marketplace — it sells manufactured goods — so it does not belong in this comparison. If you also sell manufactured goods alongside your handmade line, the Temu profit calculator covers its fees.

Frequently asked questions

Where is the best place to sell handmade items?

If you need buyers to find you, Etsy is the best starting point — it is where handmade buyers already search. If you already have an audience, your own Shopify store keeps the most of each sale. Amazon Handmade buys Amazon's traffic at 15% per sale, eBay suits one-off and vintage-adjacent pieces, and Facebook Marketplace is free only for local pickup.

How much does Etsy take on a $30 sale?

On a $30 item with no shipping charged and no sales tax, Etsy takes $3.30: a $0.20 listing fee, a 6.5% transaction fee ($1.95), and 3% + $0.25 payment processing ($1.15). You keep $26.70. Offsite Ads add 15% (or 12% once your shop passes $10,000 in trailing-12-month sales) only on sales Etsy attributes to its own ads.

Is Amazon Handmade worth it for small makers?

It depends on how much you value Amazon's traffic. Handmade charges a flat 15% referral fee on the total sale price — $4.50 on a $30 item, the highest fee in this guide — and requires an artisan application. The $39.99 monthly Professional plan fee is charged once, then waived for approved sellers. If you can already bring your own buyers, Etsy or your own store keeps more.

What does eBay charge on a $30 handmade sale?

On a $30 item with no shipping charged and no sales tax, eBay takes $4.48: a 13.6% final value fee ($4.08) plus the $0.40 per-order fee that applies to orders over $10. You keep $25.52. The first 250 listings each month are free; extra listings are $0.35 each.

Is Facebook Marketplace free for handmade sellers?

Only for local pickup paid in person — that costs nothing. Shipped orders through Marketplace checkout cost 10% of the whole transaction (item + shipping + tax), with a $0.80 minimum. On a $30 shipped item with no shipping charged, the fee is $3.00 and you keep $27.00.

When does a Shopify store beat Etsy on fees?

On a $30 sale, Shopify Basic costs $1.17 in card processing (2.9% + $0.30) against Etsy's $3.30 in fees — a $2.13 saving per order — but Shopify also charges $39 a month. At 19 orders a month the $40.47 saved beats the $39 plan cost. Below that volume Etsy is cheaper; above it, your own store wins on fees — but you must bring your own traffic.

Compare all 7 marketplaces

Keep reading: Etsy fee calculator · Shopify profit calculator · Facebook Marketplace calculator · Temu profit calculator · 7-marketplace comparison